Top Table
Discover the best restaurants, ranked by real reviews
Discover the best restaurants, ranked by real reviews
Looking for the best sicilian restaurants in New York? We analyzed 28,241 Google reviews across 17 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.
17 places in view
Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.
Sicily Osteria
Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$
Osteria Barocca
Italian restaurant · New York · $$
Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana
Italian restaurant · New York · $$
Piccola Cucina Uptown
Italian restaurant · New York · $$
Norma
Italian restaurant · New York · $$
Norma Hell's Kitchen
Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$
Concrete Sicilian Eatery
Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$$
Bleecker Street Pizza
Pizza restaurant · New York · $
Il Melograno
Italian restaurant · New York · $$
Two Boots Pizza West Village
Pizza restaurant · New York · $
Norma Turtle Bay
Italian restaurant · New York · $$
Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side
Pizza restaurant · New York · $$
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side
Pizza restaurant · New York · $$
Two Boots Pizza East Village
Pizza restaurant · New York · $
Little Italy Pizza
Pizza restaurant · New York · $
Pastai Restaurant
Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$
83 1/2
Southern Italian restaurant · New York · $$
More great dining in New York