Best Cookie Butter in Toronto

Looking for the best cookie butter in Toronto? We analyzed 2,181 Google reviews across 6 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Marry Me Mochi#1

Marry Me Mochi

Donut shop · The Junction

★ 4.8570 reviews
Andrea's Cookies#2

Andrea's Cookies

Cookie shop · Junction Triangle

★ 4.6541 reviews
Andrea's Cookies#3

Andrea's Cookies

Bakery · Ossington

★ 4.5238 reviews
M2 Cocktail Bar#4

M2 Cocktail Bar

Cocktail bar · Church-Wellesley

★ 4.6137 reviews
Craig's Cookies#5

Craig's Cookies

Cookie shop · Church-Wellesley · $$

★ 4.2635 reviews

Best Cookie Butter in Toronto

↓ See full ranking below
Top TableTop Table
6

Top Cookie Butter Spots in Toronto

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. Marry Me Mochi

    1. Marry Me Mochi

    Donut shop · The Junction

    ★ 4.8

    570 reviews

  2. Andrea's Cookies

    2. Andrea's Cookies

    Cookie shop · Junction Triangle

    ★ 4.6

    541 reviews

  3. Andrea's Cookies

    3. Andrea's Cookies

    Bakery · Ossington

    ★ 4.5

    238 reviews

  4. M2 Cocktail Bar

    4. M2 Cocktail Bar

    Cocktail bar · Church-Wellesley

    ★ 4.6

    137 reviews

  5. Craig's Cookies

    5. Craig's Cookies

    Cookie shop · Church-Wellesley · $$

    ★ 4.2

    635 reviews

  6. Andrea's Cookies

    6. Andrea's Cookies

    Bakery · Yonge & Eglinton

    ★ 4.6

    60 reviews

Discover More in Toronto

More great dining in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Cookie Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Donut Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Wholesaler Restaurants in Toronto

Vibe

Best Cute in Toronto

Vibe

Best Garden in Toronto

Dish

Best Caramel Macchiato in Toronto

Dish

Best Oreo in Toronto

Dish

Best Biscoff in Toronto

Dish

Best Chocolate Chunk in Toronto