Looking for the best cookie butter in Toronto? We analyzed 2,181 Google reviews across 6 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.
#1Marry Me Mochi
Donut shop · The Junction
#2Andrea's Cookies
Cookie shop · Junction Triangle
#3Andrea's Cookies
Bakery · Ossington
#4M2 Cocktail Bar
Cocktail bar · Church-Wellesley
#5Craig's Cookies
Cookie shop · Church-Wellesley · $$
6 places in view

“cookie butter”

“Dulche De Leche EXACTLY same flavour as cookie butter”

“cosmic brownie and cookie butter were rlly good”

“Cookie Butter”

“The cookie butter one was our favourite”

“cookie butter”
Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

1. Marry Me Mochi
Donut shop · The Junction
★ 4.8
570 reviews

2. Andrea's Cookies
Cookie shop · Junction Triangle
★ 4.6
541 reviews

3. Andrea's Cookies
Bakery · Ossington
★ 4.5
238 reviews

4. M2 Cocktail Bar
Cocktail bar · Church-Wellesley
★ 4.6
137 reviews

5. Craig's Cookies
Cookie shop · Church-Wellesley · $$
★ 4.2
635 reviews

6. Andrea's Cookies
Bakery · Yonge & Eglinton
★ 4.6
60 reviews
More great dining in Toronto