Looking for the best macaroni pie in Toronto? We analyzed 2,632 Google reviews across 6 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.
#1Vegan I Thali
Vegan restaurant · The Beaches
#2Conejo Negro
Restaurant · Little Italy
#3Miss Likklemore's
Restaurant · King West
#4The Hive by Honey Soul Food
Restaurant · Little Italy
#5Old Nassau Authentic Bahamian Cuisine
Caribbean restaurant · The Junction
6 places in view

“macaroni pie has comforting tender chew”

“mac pie dry flavorless”

“mac pie similarities Kraft dinner taste”

“macaroni pie was rich, creamy, and downright phenomenal”

“mac pie best part dinner”

“I ordered oxtail and got macaroni pie”
Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

1. Vegan I Thali
Vegan restaurant · The Beaches
★ 4.7
241 reviews

2. Conejo Negro
Restaurant · Little Italy
★ 4.5
762 reviews

3. Miss Likklemore's
Restaurant · King West
★ 4.3
831 reviews

4. The Hive by Honey Soul Food
Restaurant · Little Italy
★ 4.6
55 reviews

5. Old Nassau Authentic Bahamian Cuisine
Caribbean restaurant · The Junction
★ 4.7
566 reviews

6. Don’s Caribbean Jerk Restaurant - Toronto
Caribbean restaurant · Corso Italia
★ 4
177 reviews
More great dining in Toronto