Best New York Style Pizza in Toronto

Looking for the best new york style pizza in Toronto? We analyzed 10,780 Google reviews across 11 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Domino's Pizza#1

Domino's Pizza

Pizza delivery · Forest Hill · $

★ 4.7990 reviews
Pizzeria Libretto - University#2

Pizzeria Libretto - University

Pizza restaurant · Downtown · $$

★ 4.43,562 reviews
Pizzeria Libretto#3

Pizzeria Libretto

Pizza restaurant · Greektown / Danforth · $$

★ 4.41,787 reviews
La Famiglia On The Danforth#4

La Famiglia On The Danforth

Pizza restaurant · The Beaches · $

★ 4.5443 reviews
Domino's Pizza#5

Domino's Pizza

Pizza delivery · The Beaches · $

★ 4.2497 reviews

Best New York Style Pizza in Toronto

↓ See full ranking below
Top TableTop Table
11

Top New York Style Pizza Spots in Toronto

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. Domino's Pizza

    1. Domino's Pizza

    Pizza delivery · Forest Hill · $

    ★ 4.7

    990 reviews

  2. Pizzeria Libretto - University

    2. Pizzeria Libretto - University

    Pizza restaurant · Downtown · $$

    ★ 4.4

    3,562 reviews

  3. Pizzeria Libretto

    3. Pizzeria Libretto

    Pizza restaurant · Greektown / Danforth · $$

    ★ 4.4

    1,787 reviews

  4. La Famiglia On The Danforth

    4. La Famiglia On The Danforth

    Pizza restaurant · The Beaches · $

    ★ 4.5

    443 reviews

  5. Domino's Pizza

    5. Domino's Pizza

    Pizza delivery · The Beaches · $

    ★ 4.2

    497 reviews

  6. Domino's Pizza

    6. Domino's Pizza

    Pizza delivery · Junction Triangle · $

    ★ 4.2

    435 reviews

  7. Domino's Pizza

    7. Domino's Pizza

    Pizza delivery · Cabbagetown · $

    ★ 3.7

    751 reviews

  8. Domino's Pizza

    8. Domino's Pizza

    Pizza delivery · Willowdale · $

    ★ 4.5

    754 reviews

  9. Domino's Pizza

    9. Domino's Pizza

    Pizza delivery · Scarborough Centre · $

    ★ 4.2

    906 reviews

  10. Papa Johns Pizza

    10. Papa Johns Pizza

    Pizza restaurant · Islington Village · $

    ★ 4.2

    209 reviews

  11. Pizzeria Libretto

    11. Pizzeria Libretto

    Pizza restaurant · North York Centre · $$

    ★ 4.1

    446 reviews

Discover More in Toronto

More great dining in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Pizza Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Pizza Takeout Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Pizza Delivery Restaurants in Toronto

Vibe

Best Clean Environment in Toronto

Dish

Best Pan Pizza in Toronto

Dish

Best Cheesy Bread in Toronto

Dish

Best Funghi Pizza in Toronto

Dish

Best Neapolitan Pizza in Toronto