Best Peanut Butter Cookie in Toronto

Looking for the best peanut butter cookie in Toronto? We analyzed 5,387 Google reviews across 9 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Filosophy Pastry and Espresso Bar#1

Filosophy Pastry and Espresso Bar

Espresso bar · Koreatown · $$

★ 4.7692 reviews
Sumach Espresso#2

Sumach Espresso

Cafe · Regent Park · $

★ 4.7661 reviews
Disco Ice Cream & Cookies#3

Disco Ice Cream & Cookies

Dessert shop · Ossington

★ 4.9213 reviews
Absolute Bakery & Cafe#4

Absolute Bakery & Cafe

Bakery · Cabbagetown · $

★ 4.5544 reviews
Ricarda's Restaurant | Café | Event Venue#5

Ricarda's Restaurant | Café | Event Venue

Modern French restaurant · Chinatown · $$$

★ 4.31,437 reviews

Best Peanut Butter Cookie in Toronto

↓ See full ranking below
Top TableTop Table
9

Top Peanut Butter Cookie Spots in Toronto

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. Filosophy Pastry and Espresso Bar

    1. Filosophy Pastry and Espresso Bar

    Espresso bar · Koreatown · $$

    ★ 4.7

    692 reviews

  2. Sumach Espresso

    2. Sumach Espresso

    Cafe · Regent Park · $

    ★ 4.7

    661 reviews

  3. Disco Ice Cream & Cookies

    3. Disco Ice Cream & Cookies

    Dessert shop · Ossington

    ★ 4.9

    213 reviews

  4. Absolute Bakery & Cafe

    4. Absolute Bakery & Cafe

    Bakery · Cabbagetown · $

    ★ 4.5

    544 reviews

  5. Ricarda's Restaurant | Café | Event Venue

    5. Ricarda's Restaurant | Café | Event Venue

    Modern French restaurant · Chinatown · $$$

    ★ 4.3

    1,437 reviews

  6. Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe

    6. Almond Butterfly Bakeshop & Cafe

    Cafe · The Annex · $$

    ★ 4.4

    940 reviews

  7. Revitasize East York

    7. Revitasize East York

    Juice shop · Greektown / Danforth

    ★ 4.7

    188 reviews

  8. Au Pain Doré Bakery

    8. Au Pain Doré Bakery

    Bakery · St. Lawrence Market · $$

    ★ 4.5

    461 reviews

  9. 🍽

    9. Dineen Coffee Co

    Coffee shop · Willowdale

    ★ 4.3

    251 reviews

Discover More in Toronto

More great dining in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Ice Cream Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Health Food Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Espresso Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Juice Restaurants in Toronto

Vibe

Best Cute in Toronto

Vibe

Best Play Area in Toronto

Vibe

Best Dairy Free Options in Toronto

Vibe

Best Peaceful in Toronto

Dish

Best Milkshake in Toronto

Dish

Best Carrot Cake in Toronto

Dish

Best Birthday Cake in Toronto

Dish

Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto