Best Pumpernickel Bagel in Toronto

Looking for the best pumpernickel bagel in Toronto? We analyzed 4,678 Google reviews across 8 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Lox + Schmear

Sandwich shop · Corso Italia · $

★ 4.8569 reviews

Bagels On Fire

Bagel shop · The Beaches · $

★ 4.4664 reviews

🍽#3

The Bagel House

Bagel shop · Summerhill / Rosedale · $

★ 4.2558 reviews

What a Bagel - The Beaches

Bagel shop · The Beaches · $

★ 4.3118 reviews

St Urbain Bagel Bakery

Bagel shop · St. Lawrence Market · $

★ 3.9394 reviews

Best Pumpernickel Bagel in Toronto

↓ See full ranking below

Top Table|

8 places in view

Lox + Schmear

★ 4.8(569)Sandwich$

1 mention

“pumpernickel bagel I guess okay”

Bagels On Fire

★ 4.4(664)Bagel$

4 mentions100% positive

“My wife loves pumpernickel bagels but they are hard to find”

The Bagel House

★ 4.2(558)Bagel$

5 mentions100% positive

“I Had a great pumpernickel bagel with herb and garlic cream cheese”

What a Bagel - The Beaches

★ 4.3(118)Bagel$

4 mentions100% positive

“free pumpernickel bagels fresh off conveyor”

St Urbain Bagel Bakery

★ 3.9(394)Bagel$

3 mentions100% positive

“pumpernickel bagel my go-to”

Kettlemans Bagel

★ 3.7(874)Bagel

1 mention100% positive

“Love the pumpernickel bagels”

Happy Bagel Bakery

★ 4.6(900)Bagel$

2 mentions100% positive

“Best pumpernickle bagels in Toronto”

Bagel World

★ 4.3(601)Bagel$

5 mentions100% positive

“pumpernickel”

Best Pumpernickel Bagel in Toronto

↓ See full ranking below

Top Table|

Top Pumpernickel Bagel Spots in Toronto

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

Discover More in Toronto

More great dining in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Bagel Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Sandwich Restaurants in Toronto

Vibe

Best Busy in Toronto

Vibe

Best Early Closing in Toronto

Dish

Best Cream Cheese in Toronto

Dish

Best Everything Bagel in Toronto

Dish

Best Sesame Bagel in Toronto

Dish

Best Lox Bagel in Toronto